Review: Cinderella (1950)

Bibbidi-Bobbidi-Boo into disappointment.

Out of all the Disney Princess movies, this one stands out as one of the more "average" entries. We all know the story, so there isn't much new to say, but it is told in such a peculiar way that I can’t understand why many consider it the best. The plot is overshadowed by the mice, who dominate most of the screen time, and the cat, aptly named Lucifer. While it may seem entertaining for children, this focus detracts from the film by failing to develop the characters, particularly Cinderella, her stepmother, the stepsisters, the king, and the prince, who the movie portrays as simpletons.

Moreover, the portrayal of Cinderella herself is somewhat frustrating. While she embodies the classic archetype of the damsel in distress, her character could benefit from a stronger, more proactive presence. The narrative positions her as a passive recipient of kindness rather than an active participant in her own story. This could have been an opportunity to showcase her intelligence and resourcefulness, particularly in navigating the challenges posed by her stepfamily. By allowing her more moments of agency, the film could have transformed her character into a more relatable and empowering figure for audiences.

Additionally, the relationship between Cinderella and the Prince is another area that leaves much to be desired. Their connection feels rushed and superficial, as their interactions are limited mostly to a ball scene and a brief meeting. This lack of development makes it hard for viewers to fully invest in their romance. A deeper exploration of their personalities and shared experiences could create a more compelling love story, suggesting that true connection springs from understanding and shared values rather than mere physical attraction.

The setting itself also deserves mention. While the visuals of the palace and the magical elements are visually stunning, the world outside of these moments feels underdeveloped. There's an entire kingdom that exists beyond Cinderella’s immediate struggles, and exploring that environment could have provided context for her hardships and aspirations. Integrating scenes that highlight the socio-economic disparities within the kingdom might deepen the narrative, lending more weight to Cinderella’s desires for freedom and fulfillment.

Finally, the film's messaging about kindness and forgiveness, though well-intentioned, can come across as overly simplistic. By emphasizing these virtues without addressing the need for justice or accountability, the story risks sending a message that encourages passivity in the face of wrongdoing. While it’s important to promote kindness, the lack of consequences for Cinderella's stepfamily’s actions can feel disheartening.

In summary, while Cinderella undoubtedly holds a cherished place in the Disney canon with its enchanting visuals and memorable music, there lies a wealth of untapped potential in its storytelling. More nuanced character development, richer relationships, and a deeper exploration of themes could elevate it from a simple fairy tale to a resonant narrative about resilience, agency, and the complexity of human relationships. As it stands, Cinderella’s tale, while beloved, leaves audiences yearning for a more profound and empowering journey.

Rating: 3/4 stars.